For homeowners choosing how to use their equity 5.0 out of 5,38 Google reviews

HELOC vs cash out refinance Which costs less in Florida?

The cheaper option depends on your current rate, how much you need and for how long. Here's a fair comparison, and a way to run it on your own numbers.

Robert Staab, independent mortgage broker in South Florida
Robert Staab

Owner and licensed mortgage broker, Royal Capital Solutions.

Licensed in Florida
NMLS 1474183 Verify license

Should I get a HELOC or do a cash out refinance?

If your current mortgage rate is lower than today's, a HELOC or home equity loan usually costs less, because only the new money carries the new rate. If your rate is higher than today's, or you need a large amount, a cash out refinance can win, because it resets the whole loan.

Robert Staab, NMLS 1474183

Side by side.

Three ways to use your equity.

Side by side.
HELOCHome equity loanCash out refinance
Your first mortgageStays as it isStays as it isReplaced
Which balance gets the new rateOnly what you drawOnly the new loanThe whole loan
How you get moneyDraw as neededAll at onceAll at once
RateUsually variableUsually fixedFixed or adjustable
Closing costsUsually lowerUsually lowerFull refinance costs
PaymentInterest only at first, then risesFixedOne payment

How to compare the cost for your numbers.

No rate examples here. Use your own quotes, step by step.

Not sure which wins for you? Robert runs both.

When cash out wins, and when a HELOC wins.

A HELOC or home equity loan usually wins

  • Your first mortgage rate is lower than today's
  • You need a smaller amount, or need it in stages
  • You want lower closing costs
  • You'll pay it back within a few years

A cash out refinance usually wins

  • Your current rate is higher than today's
  • You need a large amount relative to your loan
  • You want one fixed payment
  • You want to remove FHA mortgage insurance at the same time

How it works with Robert.

Everything happens by phone and online, so you never need to come in. Closing can be digital, or a mobile notary comes to you.

  1. Step 01 / 04

    A short first call

    About 15 to 20 minutes. Robert asks what you want the money to do and how much you need, then about your current loan, your equity, credit and income, and runs both options.

  2. Step 02 / 04

    Application and a game plan

    You apply online, on your own or with Robert on the phone. He sends a list of documents and compares the options, including leaving your loan alone if that's better.

  3. Step 03 / 04

    Lenders and the appraisal

    Robert shops lenders for your scenario, sends your disclosures and orders title and the appraisal where one is needed, and tells you what the underwriter needs.

  4. Step 04 / 04

    Closing

    Digital, or a mobile notary comes to you. On a refinance or home equity loan on a home you live in, federal law gives you three business days to change your mind before funds are released.

Loans other lenders said no to.

Real files from Robert's clients, with details changed for privacy.

Case file 01 · Orlando · PurchaseLoan closed

Turned down in the last week of the contract.

  1. Denied

    The lender said her debt-to-income ratio was too high, days before closing, and her deposit was at risk.

  2. Robert's review

    Her ratio was close. Robert asked the income questions the first lender skipped and found a confirmed raise starting within 90 days, which lenders can count with a letter from the employer.

  3. Outcome

    The employer's letter confirmed the raise, the numbers worked, and the loan closed before her contract deadline.

Case file 02 · Brickell · Condo purchaseLoan closed

A high-rise "in litigation" that was not a risk.

  1. Denied

    Another lender turned the buyer down because the building was in litigation, which most lenders treat as an automatic no.

  2. Robert's review

    Robert called the management company and learned the association was the one suing, over the parking garage built next to it. He asked the association's attorney to confirm that in writing.

  3. Outcome

    The attorney's letter cleared it and the loan closed. Robert has since closed five more loans in the same building.

Case file 03 · Downtown Miami · Condo purchaseLoan closed

A lawsuit over a pool leak that was already repaired.

  1. Denied

    The lender denied the loan because an owner was suing the building over water damage.

  2. Robert's review

    Robert learned the damage came from a pool leak, the repairs were finished, and the association had the reserves to cover them without charging owners.

  3. Outcome

    He found a lender that would accept the building with a letter from the association, and the loan closed.

Comparison questions.

Don't see your question? Robert answers the phone himself.

Call Robert
Which is better, refinance or a home equity loan?

It depends on your current rate. With a low first mortgage rate, a home equity loan usually costs less. With a high one, a refinance can save more.

Is it better to do a cash out refinance or a HELOC?

A HELOC suits smaller or staged needs and keeps your first mortgage. A cash out refinance suits large amounts, or when today's rates beat yours.

What are the pros and cons of a HELOC vs a refinance?

HELOC: lower costs, keeps your rate, but variable and the payment rises later. Refinance: one fixed payment, but higher costs and the whole balance resets.

Should I refinance or take a home equity loan?

Compare the total cost over the years you'll keep the home, including closing costs, using real quotes for both.

Let Robert run both on your numbers.

For example the building, your price range or what happened before. Please don't include account numbers or your credit score.

We use your details only to review your file. Privacy policy

Cookie settings

Choose which services can run on this site. You can change this at any time from Cookie settings in the footer.

Essential

The site and the enquiry form need these to work, so they are always on.

Always on
  • Site session and security Royal Capital Solutions (this site)

    Keeps your enquiry form working and protects it against forged requests.

    Cookies set by Site session and security
    CookieKept for
    royal-capital-solutions-session2 hours
    XSRF-TOKEN2 hours
  • Your cookie choice Royal Capital Solutions (this site)

    Remembers what you choose here, so we do not ask on every page.

    Cookies set by Your cookie choice
    CookieKept for
    rc_consent12 months
  • Spam protection (Cloudflare Turnstile) Cloudflare, Inc.

    Checks that an enquiry comes from a person before it is sent. Loads only on pages with an enquiry form.

    Your IP address and browser details are sent to Cloudflare for the check. We set no cookie for it.

    Cloudflare, Inc. privacy policy
  • Saved form answers Royal Capital Solutions (this site)

    Keeps your answers if you reload a form before sending it.

    Held in your browser tab only and cleared when you close it. We receive it only if you send the enquiry.

  • Fonts (Google Fonts) Google LLC

    Delivers the typefaces the site is set in.

    Google receives your IP address and browser details to send the font files. It sets no cookie.

    Google LLC privacy policy

Analytics

Helps us see which pages and buttons are useful. Off unless you allow it.

  • Google Analytics 4 Google LLC

    Counts visits and shows which pages and buttons (for example File review and Call) people use, and which page a visit started on, so we can improve the site.

    Pages viewed, button clicks, approximate location, device and browser type. Google may process this outside the United States. We turn off Google's advertising features.

    Cookies set by Google Analytics 4
    CookieKept for
    _ga2 years
    _ga_2 years
    Google LLC privacy policy
  • PostHog PostHog, Inc.

    Shows how visitors move through the site and which buttons and forms get used, so we can improve it. No session recording and nothing you type is captured.

    Pages viewed, button clicks, approximate location, device and browser type.

    Cookies set by PostHog
    CookieKept for
    ph_*_posthog1 year
    PostHog, Inc. privacy policy

Your choice is saved in a cookie called rc_consent for 12 months. See our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy, or write to our team.